Facebook Instagram LinkedIn YouTube TikTok

The Numbers Can Work and the Decision Can Still Be Wrong

I once had someone bring me a really good real estate deal. There were plenty of reasons to look at it seriously, and from a financial standpoint I could have justified continuing the conversation. Then I spent more time with the person who brought it to me, and something happened that had nothing to do with the property.

We were at a restaurant, and I watched the way this person treated our waitress. The interaction made her visibly uncomfortable. There was no difficult negotiation taking place and no disagreement over money. She was simply doing her job, and I was watching how someone behaved toward a person who had very little power in that moment.

I remember thinking that if this is how you treat a waitress in an ordinary setting, what happens when you are frustrated with a resident? How do you speak to a vendor when an invoice is higher than expected? What happens when an employee makes a mistake, or when an investor begins asking uncomfortable questions because the property is not performing the way everyone hoped?

I chose not to do the deal. The property had not changed, and neither had the financial opportunity. What changed was my understanding of the person I would have been going into business with.

That experience stayed with me because it reinforced something I already believed. Our personal ethics have a way of following us into business. We can try to separate the two, but eventually the way we view people, money, responsibility, and truth shows up in the way we operate. A spreadsheet can tell me whether a property may work financially, but it cannot tell me everything I need to know about the people attached to it.

The Numbers Are Only Part of the Decision

Real estate teaches us to analyze everything. We study rents, expenses, financing, repairs, cash flow, and returns because those numbers help us determine whether a property makes sense. I believe deeply in doing that work because being a good steward means understanding what you are buying and making informed decisions with the money entrusted to you.

But there are decisions the spreadsheet cannot make for you. The numbers can tell you that rents are below market, but they cannot decide how you communicate a rent increase to residents. They can show you that reducing an expense improves cash flow, but they cannot tell you whether the thing being eliminated is something the property genuinely needs. They can show you the projected return on a partnership, but they cannot tell you whether the person sitting across the table is someone you want beside you when the deal becomes difficult.

My faith shapes how I think about those questions. Scripture speaks repeatedly about honesty, stewardship, justice, and how we treat people. Proverbs 11:1 talks about dishonest scales, and while the marketplace looks different today, the principle remains the same. How we conduct business matters, especially when being completely honest or fair is less convenient than the alternative.

There are decisions I may have every legal right to make that I still need to think through before deciding whether they are right for me to make. That does not mean avoiding difficult business decisions. Real estate ownership requires plenty of them. Rents sometimes need to increase, contracts need to be enforced, expenses need to be controlled, and relationships with vendors or employees sometimes need to end. The question is not whether everyone will always like the decision. The question is whether I can defend the way I arrived at it.

Character Becomes Part of Due Diligence

Two people shaking hands over documents at the start of a partnership

The restaurant experience changed the way I look at potential business relationships because it reminded me that character often reveals itself long before there is a serious problem.

People usually know how to behave when they need something from you. A potential partner can be thoughtful when discussing your money. Someone trying to sell you on a deal can be generous with compliments. A broker, lender, or investor can be perfectly professional when the relationship benefits both sides. Those interactions matter, but I also pay attention to what happens when there is nothing obvious to gain.

I notice how someone treats the waitress, the maintenance person, the assistant, the vendor, or the person who cannot help move the deal forward. I listen to how they talk about partners who are not in the room and how they respond when somebody makes a mistake. Those moments may seem unrelated to real estate, but I do not believe they are.

Matthew 7:16 speaks about recognizing people by their fruit. I do not take that to mean we should judge someone completely based on one bad interaction. We all have bad days, and none of us handles every situation perfectly. What matters to me is whether the behavior reveals a pattern that I should take seriously.

A partnership gives another person’s judgment and character influence over things that matter to me. Their decisions may affect residents, investors, vendors, employees, the property itself, and my reputation. That makes character part of my due diligence just as surely as reviewing the rent roll or inspecting the roof.

I can hire someone to verify financial statements and inspect physical systems. There is no inspection report that tells me how someone will behave when money is tight, emotions are high, and doing the right thing becomes inconvenient. Sometimes the best information comes from simply watching how they already treat people.

Good Intentions Still Have Consequences

Ethical decisions are not only about the character of the people around us. They also require us to examine our own decisions, particularly when the outcome does not match what we intended.

We naturally judge ourselves by our intentions because we know what we meant to do. An owner may delay a repair because they are trying to preserve cash. A manager may enforce a policy because consistency matters. A partner may make a decision believing it is best for the property. Those intentions may be sincere, but the people affected by the decision still experience the result.

If delaying a repair allows a manageable issue to become a much larger problem, then the consequence needs to be considered. If cutting an expense saves money but creates turnover, deferred maintenance, or a poor resident experience, then the decision deserves another look. If a policy is being followed exactly as written but consistently produces a result that was never intended, responsible ownership means being willing to ask whether the policy still makes sense.

Micah 6:8 speaks about acting justly, loving mercy, and walking humbly. I think humility belongs in business because it requires us to admit that we can make a thoughtful decision and still learn something afterward that changes our perspective. We do not have to defend every original decision simply because it was ours.

A bad outcome does not automatically mean the decision was unethical. Real estate involves uncertainty, and sometimes a responsible decision still produces a disappointing result. What matters is whether we are willing to examine what happened, understand the effect of our decision, and make a better one next time.

Stewardship Includes People, Not Just Money

Well kept apartment courtyard with a resident and a maintenance worker

When we talk about stewardship in real estate, money usually comes to mind first. If someone trusts me with capital, I take that responsibility seriously. But stewardship is larger than protecting the bank account.

Residents are trusting ownership to maintain the property. Lenders are trusting us to protect the asset. Vendors are trusting that they will be treated fairly and paid for their work. Employees and property managers are trusting us to communicate expectations clearly. Partners are trusting that we will tell them what is happening, including when the news is not what any of us hoped to hear.

That means the least expensive decision today is not always the most responsible decision over time. I can postpone maintenance and make this month’s expenses look better, but I may create a much larger bill later. I can avoid an uncomfortable conversation with a partner for another month, but I may damage trust once they discover I knew something and did not communicate it. I can squeeze every vendor on price, but eventually the vendors I actually want may decide they no longer want to work with me.

Luke 16:10 speaks about faithfulness in small things, and business gives us countless opportunities to practice that. Most ethical problems do not begin with one enormous decision. They begin with smaller choices that seemed too insignificant to matter at the time.

That is one reason the restaurant experience mattered so much to me. It was a small moment, but it showed me something about how that person handled a situation where they had the power and someone else did not.

The Decision Usually Reaches More People Than We Think

Real estate ownership gets complicated because almost every meaningful decision affects more than one person. A rent increase affects the resident and the property’s income. A repair decision affects the person living with the problem, the condition of the asset, and the investors paying the bill. Changing property management affects employees, residents, vendors, and ownership.

There is rarely a decision where everyone gets exactly what they want, and I do not think ethical ownership means trying to create that impossible outcome. It means understanding the responsibilities attached to the decision and thinking seriously about who will carry the result.

Decision What I Feel Responsible For What I Need to Think Through
Raising rents Honoring leases and communicating clearly Effect on residents, collections, turnover, and the property
Delaying a repair Protecting the property and providing what residents are entitled to expect Whether waiting creates a larger problem or unnecessary hardship
Choosing a partner Protecting investors, residents, the business, and my reputation How this person’s character may show up when the deal becomes difficult
Cutting an expense Operating responsibly without wasting money Whether the savings create another problem somewhere else
Presenting a deal Being truthful about what I know and what I do not know What happens to someone else’s money if my assumptions are wrong
Enforcing a policy Applying standards consistently Whether the policy is accomplishing what it was designed to accomplish

When I am working through a difficult decision, one of the questions I come back to is whether I could explain the reasoning if I were sitting on the other side of the table. If this were my money, would I believe I had been given the whole story? If I were the resident, would I believe the policy had been applied fairly? If I were the vendor, would I believe the expectations were clear before the disagreement happened?

Matthew 7:12 gives us what we call the Golden Rule: treat others the way we would want to be treated. That does not mean giving everyone the answer they want. It means applying the same honesty, fairness, and consideration we would hope to receive if the roles were reversed.

That simple standard can cut through a lot of complicated business language.

Reputation Is Built Long Before the Big Decision

We tend to think our professional reputation is created during negotiations, investor meetings, closings, and major business decisions. I think it is being built in much smaller places as well.

It is being built in the restaurant, in conversations with employees, in how we respond when a contractor tells us something we do not want to hear, and in the way we communicate when a property is struggling. Those moments show people what doing business with us will feel like when circumstances are not easy.

Real estate is too relational for character to stay hidden forever. Brokers remember who follows through. Partners remember whether you communicated when a property was behind plan. Vendors remember whether they were paid and treated fairly. Employees remember whether expectations changed depending on who benefited from the decision.

You can win a transaction and damage a relationship at the same time, and that cost will never appear in the original underwriting.

Trust is built slowly through repeated behavior. Once I began thinking about business that way, ethics stopped feeling like something separate from real estate. The way we conduct ourselves eventually becomes part of the value people assign to working with us.

Frequently Asked Questions

How should faith influence real estate investing?

For me, faith affects how I think about stewardship, honesty, responsibility, character, and how my decisions affect other people. It does not mean ignoring profitability. A financially unhealthy property eventually creates its own problems. Faith simply means profit is not the only measure I use.

Should someone’s personal behavior affect whether you choose a business partner?

I believe it deserves consideration. A partnership gives another person’s judgment and character influence over decisions that may affect money, residents, investors, and your reputation. One bad moment does not define someone, but patterns in how a person treats others can tell you something financial statements cannot.

Does ethical ownership mean avoiding rent increases or difficult business decisions?

No. Responsible ownership sometimes requires difficult decisions. What matters is whether those decisions are made honestly, consistently, and with consideration for the people affected by them.

Can you make the right decision and still have a bad outcome?

Yes. We make decisions using imperfect information, and a bad result does not automatically prove that the original decision was wrong. What matters is whether we examine what happened, learn from it, and allow that experience to improve our judgment.

There Are Things the Spreadsheet Cannot Tell You

I still want the spreadsheet. I want to know what the property is worth, what the rents can support, what the expenses look like, where the risk is, and what return makes sense for the money being invested. Those are part of being responsible with an investment.

I simply know that the spreadsheet reaches a point where it cannot answer the rest of the questions for me.

It cannot tell me whether the person bringing me the deal treats people with dignity. It cannot tell me whether a partner will communicate honestly when things become uncomfortable or whether someone will treat a resident fairly when there is nothing financially rewarding about doing so. It cannot tell me whether I will be proud of the way I handled a decision after the financial result is known.

My faith is part of how I answer those questions.

At Ignite RE Wealth, I teach investors to understand the numbers because they matter enormously. But the longer I have owned real estate, the more convinced I have become that we are not only building portfolios. We are building a reputation for the kind of people we are while we build them.

Sometimes the numbers will tell you that you can do the deal. Character, stewardship, and faith may still be the things that tell you whether you should.

Build Your Real Estate Business on More Than Numbers

Strong real estate investing requires sound financial analysis, thoughtful decision-making, and responsible ownership. Develop your multifamily investing knowledge and learn to approach opportunities with greater clarity and confidence.

Explore the Mentorship Program

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *